The Zodiac: Sidereal or Tropical?
Last week in Astronews, Bernard Fitzwalter observed that Jupiter can
currently be seen near the twin stars of Gemini. But, astrologically
speaking, Jupiter is not in Gemini, it's in Cancer. Here, Bernard explains
why.
(If you missed any of Friday's Astronews articles, click on the Archive Thought for the Day link in the left hand frame.)
If you look up at Jupiter one night this month, having read on this page that
it's in Cancer, you'll see it next to the twin stars of Gemini. So why isn't
it in Cancer? The simple answer is that there are two zodiacs, and they're
not the same. In the 'tropical' zodiac Jupiter is in Cancer; but in the
'sidereal' or star-based zodiac, it's in Gemini.
The planets all move through a strip of the sky that encircles the globe. We
call this strip the ecliptic. Along it are the 12 constellations, each
carrying the name of a zodiac sign. These constellations are of different
sizes and, even in India, where most traditional astrologers still work
directly with them, there is much debate about exactly where one sign ends
and the next begins.
Most western astrologers, though, don't use this zodiac. Instead, very
deliberately, they use the tropical zodiac. This zodiac divides the Sun's
apparent path through the ecliptic into 12 exactly equal sections. These
sections are named after the traditional constellations which is where
confusion can sometimes arise. The two systems are very different and western
astrologers have good reasons for preferring the more precise tropical
zodiac. Some who have experimented with the two systems side by side find
that the tropical zodiac gives sharper results in questions of timing.